All Saints' Day, Feast day
Comments 7

All Saints’ or Reformation Day?

Thank you to Anna-Kathryn Kline for this reflection on All Saints’ Day. Anna-Kathryn is a military spouse who uses the liturgical year to provide stability and familiarity to her home. She is the privileged stay-at-home mother of three little girls and spends her days rediscovering her childhood by coming alongside her girls in the pursuit of wonder.

This is the first year my family will be celebrating All Saints’ Day and I’m really excited about it. And, quite frankly, I’m excited to be excited. For the past few years, October 31st (Reformation Day) and November 1st (All Saints’) have been strange days for me full of new feelings. Our new catholic (lower case) beliefs have given us a strong desire to see the unity of the Church and grief over the lack of brotherly love and unity we see before us:

“For as the body is one, and hath many members, and all the members of that one body, being many, are one body: so also is Christ.” 1 Cor. 12:12

“Forbearing one another, and forgiving one another, if any man have a quarrel against any: even as Christ forgave you, so also do ye.” Col. 3:13

I could, of course, go on, but I will move on to what my conundrum about Reformation has been the past couple years: How is it forgiving, how is it loving, how is it promoting unity among God’s true body on Earth to celebrate a day of schism? Regarding the Reformation, certainly reforms were needed. Regarding theological differences, certainly continued dialogue is needed. However, much, even the majority of what I see and hear from friends and on social media is a dismissal of ecclesial community in favor of a football game-style chant of “WE WON . . . .” You fill in the missing words with what you hear at football games or on Reformation day.

What happened to, “Finally, be ye all of one mind, having compassion one of another, love as brethren, be pitiful, be courteous” (1 Peter 3:8).

A friend recently asked me if I would be okay with Reformation Day if it were more along the lines of St. Martin Luther Day. I laughed and thought what a great idea. It is good to recognize the bravery of the reformers. I continue to use “A Mighty Fortress is Our God” for all of October to daily sing with my littles. Yet I also pray, so that my children can hear me, for the unity of His body and the reconciliation of believers.

In his book Heavenly Participation: The Weaving of a Sacramental Tapestry, Hans Boersma says this about the current Christian climate:

“What we need is evangelicals and Catholics who discern the primary demand of our time: a celebration of our heavenly participation in the eternal Word of God. Only a heavenly minded Christian faith will do us any earthly good” (p. 99).

Though Boersma does not make any connection to All Saints’ Day, I did. What could be more purposeful in pursuing unity of the Body than to recognize the saints gone before us and to celebrate the communion of saints past and present? Now do you see why I’m excited this year? Instead of focusing on disunity, this year our house will focus on the heavenly participation of saints and their relationship to us now on Earth.

All Saints’ Day is a beautiful holy day where we celebrate all those who have entered Heaven, even those saints known only to God (in other words, not official saints of the Church). It is common practice to celebrate deceased family members who, without their testimony and guidance, we wouldn’t have the Christian heritage that we claim. In some cultures, this is a day to visit graves and repair them or simply leave flowers. Of course, we also celebrate recognized saints. One of the most common tradition for children is to dress up as saints. Two days of dress up?! My kids will be thrilled. I marvel at the fittingness of Halloween (All Hallows’ Eve) with All Saints’ Day. On Halloween, children dress up to make fun of death (1Cor. 15:55). Then, we immediately dress up as those who have already attained Heaven in place of death.

Since this is my first year of celebrating All Saints’ Day, I have no traditions to share. All my activities will be from a Pinterest search for All Saints’ Day. My favorite ideas have come from and Because I need to do things in baby steps, I will not be attempting to sew new costumes for my kiddos. However, I found beautiful coloring pages, paper bag puppet saint templates, recipes, and games to play. I particularly liked the idea of making our Armor of God and putting it on so that we become saints. We memorized Ephesians 6: 10-18 last year and I’m grateful for a fun way to sneak in review.

There will be prayer for the unity of the church, there will be “A Mighty Fortress is Our God” sung at the top of our lungs while we march in our armor, there will be saint stories read and family saint stories shared.

We will end the day with a flaming cupcake. I particularly liked this because it will give me a chance to tell one of my favorite stories (Forgive me, I have no reference):
There were two monks walking in a desert. One was sharing how he really admired his companion and wished he could be filled with the Holy Spirit as he was. His companion told him to look at him and tell him what he saw. The monk was filled with awe and gasped that he saw flames coming from his eyes. His companion said, “I, too, see flames coming from your eyes. No more complaining. You have the Holy Spirit.”

In fact, we all have the Holy Spirit and through prayer we can fan a little flame until it becomes a roaring fire, just like what we see in a saint’s eye.

Featured image: Detail from Fra Angelico: The Last Judgement




  1. Lanna says

    As a Protestant who has been questioning a lot and feeling a draw to learn more about the catholic faith in the last year or so, I really appreciate this. I feel the same- why celebrate a schism when we should be working toward unity and love? I appreciate all of the links you shared and the way this website in general makes all these feasts accessible to people like me! ❤️


  2. This is so lovely! I am a confirmed Anglican, so you would think I of all people would be celebrating Reformation Day. No–it grieves me. I did see a lot of “HA WE WON!” in my social media browsing. (Maybe not those exact words, but the sentiment…) I much prefer the joy and unity of All Saints!


  3. Alastair Donaldson says

    Like many events /periods of time, the whole of the reformation only has one day allocated to it. In many ways we are called to acknowledge how the reformation was already taking place for several centuries and indeed to acknowledge how the church is continually reforming. All that said, the 16th Century events sparked by Luther and commonly known as the reformation were a highly significant time in the purifying of God’s Church. The corruptions and lapses of the time were immense not to mention the complete lack of access to the scriptures for the common man/woman. Was everything connected with the ‘Reformation’ conducted correctly and charitably? Of course not. But it’s easy for us with 21st century minds to look back with disdain and condemn such an event for ‘it’s lack of unity’. However, when we assess the actual ‘need’ for the reformation and God’s intentions in bringing it about, perhaps we might conclude differently?


  4. Anna Kline says

    Thank you for your thoughtful comment! To clarify, I didn’t want to give the impression of disputing the need for the Reformation itself, but rather, perhaps, the modern celebration of it.


  5. Hello! I just found your blog and am loving it. Thank you so much for your writing and for the resources you offer. I am using your print-out for Advent readings!

    May I ask what you mean by “catholic”? I was always taught that lowercase-catholic meant simply the church universal, or all Christians together as a body, however divided. However, I sense that you are using it in a different sense, and would love to learn more.

    Looking forward to reading your blog – thank you!


  6. K in Philly says

    1 For all the saints, who from their labors rest,
    who thee by faith before the world confessed,
    thy name, O Jesus, be forever bless’d.
    Alleluia, alleluia!

    2 Thou wast their rock, their refuge, and their might,
    thou, Christ, the hope that put their fears to flight;
    ’mid gloom and doubt, their true and shining light.
    Alleluia, alleluia!

    3 Oh, bless’d communion, fellowship divine!
    We feebly struggle, they in glory shine,
    yet all are one in thee, for all are thine.
    Alleluia, alleluia!

    4 The golden evening brightens in the west.
    Soon, soon to faithful servants cometh rest.
    Sweet is the calm of paradise the bless’d.
    Alleluia, alleluia!

    5 But lo! There breaks a yet more glorious day;
    the saints triumphant rise in bright array,
    as God to glory calls them all away.
    Alleluia, alleluia!

    6 From earth’s wide bounds, from ocean’s farthest coast,
    through gates of pearl streams in the countless host,
    *all praising Father, Son, and Holy Ghost.
    Alleluia, alleluia


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s